The short version: Meritage Homes is selling move-in-ready homes in Madison Preserve two ways right now. Some come with a 5.5% fixed rate plus up to $10,000 toward closing costs. Others carry no incentives and are priced $25,000 to $40,000 lower for a similar plan. Which one costs you less depends on how long you keep the loan, not on which number sounds bigger.
Where Madison Preserve is and what's built there
Madison Preserve is a Meritage Homes community with a Madison mailing address (ZIP 35756), but it sits in Limestone County. Homes are new, built in 2025 and 2026, on small lots of roughly 4,800 to 7,400 square feet. Plans run from about 1,400 to 2,700 square feet, with three to five bedrooms. The listings show public sewer on almost every home and an HOA fee of $600 (the MLS field doesn't say how often it is billed, so ask).
In the 12 months of Valley MLS closings through November 5, 2026, 55 homes sold in Madison Preserve. Meritage's own office listed 54 of them; one was a resale. That's half of the 109 sales listed for the Tanner High zone over the same period.
| Madison Preserve, Valley MLS | Count | Median price | Range | Median $/sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sold, Dec 2, 2025 - Nov 5, 2026 | 55 | $303,990 | $248,990 - $405,000 | $166 |
| Active, Nov 13, 2026 | 19 | $309,990 | $249,990 - $389,990 | $172 |
| Under contract, Nov 13, 2026 | 4 | $304,990 | $246,470 - $377,315 | $173 |
Sold homes closed at a median of 98.7% of their final list price, and the median time from listing to closing was 135 days. Many of these homes are listed while still under construction, so that number includes build time. For the full picture on recent Madison Preserve sales by street and size, see our neighborhood page.
Two ways to buy the same plan
Read the listing remarks for the 19 homes for sale on November 13, and 18 of them fall into two groups:
- Rate plus closing help (12 homes): a 30-year fixed rate of 5.5% (4.99% on one home) plus up to $10,000 toward closing costs, with the refrigerator, washer, dryer and blinds included. The remarks say financing, terms and eligibility apply.
- Lowest price, no incentives (6 homes): same appliances included, but no rate or closing-cost help. The price is lower instead.
Here's how the asking prices line up for matching floor plans:
| Plan size | With 5.5% rate + closing help | Price only | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1,397 sq ft, 3 bed | $274,990 | $249,990 | $25,000 |
| 1,648 sq ft, 3 bed | $319,990 | $289,990 | $30,000 |
| 1,725 sq ft, 3 bed | $299,990 (8197 Gaskin Blvd) | $269,990 (8231 Huspa Ave) | $30,000 |
| 2,702 sq ft, 4 bed | $369,990 | $329,990 | $40,000 |
Lots, elevations and options can differ between two homes with the same square footage, so part of each gap may be the house, not the incentive. Ask the builder for the base price and the options on each one.
Running the numbers on one pair
Take the 1,725 square foot pair: $299,990 with the 5.5% rate, or $269,990 at whatever rate you get on your own. Freddie Mac's weekly average for a 30-year fixed was 7.11% on November 12, 2026 (see mortgage rates this week). With 10% down, principal and interest only:
| $299,990 at 5.5% | $269,990 at 7.11% | |
|---|---|---|
| Down payment (10%) | $29,999 | $26,999 |
| Loan amount | $269,991 | $242,991 |
| Monthly principal and interest | $1,533 | $1,635 |
| Builder help toward closing costs | up to $10,000 | none |
| Loan balance after 5 years | about $249,600 | about $229,000 |
The rate version saves about $102 a month and covers more of your closing costs. The price version leaves you owing about $20,600 less after five years. Three things decide which one wins for you:
- How long you keep the loan. If you plan to stay put with this mortgage for many years, a fixed 5.5% rate is hard to beat. If you sell in a few years, the smaller loan balance matters more.
- Whether rates fall. If rates drop and you refinance, the low rate you paid for goes away, but the higher price stays in your loan. On the cheaper home, a refinance to 6% would put the payment at about $1,457, lower than the 5.5% home. Refinancing has its own costs, and nobody can promise where rates go.
- Your real outside rate. Freddie Mac's average assumes strong credit and 20% down. Get a quote from an outside lender on the same day you price the builder's offer. Also ask whether the 5.5% applies to FHA, VA and conventional loans, and whether it requires the builder's lender.
Our rate buydown calculator lets you plug in your own price, rate and down payment. Property taxes and insurance also run a little higher on the higher price. If you're weighing a nearby resale too, try the new vs. resale calculator.
Price cuts this fall
Seventeen of the 19 homes for sale had a price cut between October 30 and November 10, ranging from $3,000 to $40,000. One home's price went up $10,000 in the same stretch, and it's the one now offered at 4.99%. Builders adjust prices and offers often, so compare this week's numbers on our builder incentives page with what you're quoted in the model.
Schools and taxes
Listings here name Tanner for elementary, middle and high school (Limestone County Schools). Tanner High School earned a C (74) on the 2024-25 state report card; the 2025-26 report cards weren't out when we checked. A Madison address here does not mean Madison City Schools, which we covered in our post on what the Madison City zone adds to home prices. Confirm the zone by address with Limestone County Schools before you buy.
Taxes follow Limestone County, and the rate depends on whether a lot is inside Madison city limits. Ask the builder which applies and see our Alabama property tax guide. For drive times to Redstone Arsenal and Research Park, see commute times and traffic.
Before you sign with any builder
- Get both offers in writing for the exact home: price, rate, points, closing-cost credit and the lender required.
- Ask how long the rate lock lasts and what happens if closing slips.
- Hire your own licensed home inspector for a pre-drywall and a final inspection, even on a new home.
We compared another Madison community the same way in our Clift Farm post, and you can line up builders on our builder comparison page.
Let us run your numbers
Wyze Realty is a local family business, and I've worked in Alabama real estate for more than 10 years. Tell us your budget and how long you plan to stay, and we'll put the builder's rate offer next to the lower price and an outside lender's quote, pull recent sales near the homes you like, and show you resale homes in the same price range nearby. Call or text me at (256) 808-6861 or send us a note. - George Lensch, Broker-Owner
Sources: Valley MLS data via wyzerealty.com, sales of homes, townhomes and condos with closings Dec 2, 2025 - Nov 5, 2026, and active listings and listing remarks as of Nov 13, 2026; payments are estimates of principal and interest only; Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey, Nov 12, 2026; Alabama State Department of Education 2024-25 report card. Builder offers change often and may have eligibility rules. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.