Search Buffalo Creek Estates

Toney · ZIP 35773

Buffalo Creek Estates Homes for Sale and Home Values

About 119 lots, platted from 1988 to 1996, with mostly one-story homes built 1992 to 2000, typically about 1,250 sq ft on lots of about half an acre.

$223,500Median sale price12 resales, last 3 years
$166Per square footresales, last 3 years
5Homes for sale nowplus 0 under contract
1 in 30Homes sell here each yearabout typical for the neighborhoods we track

As of November 1, 2026. Compiled by Wyze Realty.

See Homes for SaleWhat's My Home Worth?

Buffalo Creek Estates Homes for Sale

As of November 1, 2026, 5 homes are for sale in Buffalo Creek Estates, asking $199,999 to $246,000 (median $200,000, about $179 per sq ft), with 0 under contract.

Swipe sideways to see all 5 homes.

See Every Home for Sale on the Map

How Often Homes Sell Here

About 1 in 30 Homes Sells Each Year

How Often and When Homes List Here

12 resales in 3 years; busiest month: June

Over the last 3 years, 12 resale homes sold here out of about 119 lots, roughly 4 a year, or roughly one every three months. That is close to the middle of the neighborhoods we track.

When Buffalo Creek Estates homes were listed over the last 3 years. Listings were spread across 7 of the 12 months; June was the busiest (3). The median home took 64 days from listing to closing in the last 3 years.

Waiting for the Right Home Here?Join the waiting list and we will email you the day a Buffalo Creek Estates home hits the market. Free, and you can stop the emails any time.
Join the Waiting List

Buffalo Creek Estates Home Values

What's My Home Worth Here?

Enter your home's finished square footage for an instant range based on similar-size Buffalo Creek Estates sales.

For another size, call (256) 808-6861 or request a free value.

$200,000 to $255,000

For a typical 1,250 sq ft home here. Middle of the range: about $215,000. Based on 10 Buffalo Creek Estates resales between 1,083 and 1,412 sq ft in the last 3 years.

Get My Exact ValueGet Monthly Value Updates

Size-only estimate, not an appraisal. Kitchens, roofs, lots and streets can move a home above or below it. For your exact value, ask for a free, no-pressure walk-through.

What Homes Like Yours Sold For

Most sales: under 1,600 sq ft, median $222K

Resale homes in Buffalo Creek Estates over the last 3 years, grouped by size. Find your home's size for the quickest honest starting point. Most sales here were in the under 1,600 group.

Home sizeSalesMedianRange
Under 1,600 sq ft11$222K$151K to $244K$171 per sq ft
1,600 to 1,9991$245Kone sale$147 per sq ft

Price per Square Foot Over Time

$162 to $158: slipping a little

Each point is the median price per square foot of resales in the 12 months ending that month. It went from $162 in the year to August 2025 to $158 now: slipping a little.

$140$150$160$170Aug '25Nov '25Jan '26May '26Aug '26$162$158
Show the numbers
12 months toSalesMedian pricePer sq ft
Aug 20255$225,000$162
Nov 20253$219,900$147
Jan 20264$207,450$152
May 20264$207,450$152
Aug 20263$219,000$158

How the Market Is Moving

64 days listing to closing, 98.3% of asking, buyer-leaning market

These use the last 3 years because fewer than 3 homes resold here in the last 12 months.

64 daysmedian from listing to closing (6 of 12 closed within 60 days)
98.3%of the original asking price, median
5 of 12sellers lowered the price before selling
30.0 monthsof supply at the last year's pace, a buyer-leaning market

Homes for sale now ask about $179 per sq ft against $166 for recent sales. Listings priced near recent sales have moved faster than the stretch-priced ones.

Recent Home Sales in Buffalo Creek Estates

The 10 most recent sales. Street names only; days are from listing to closing.

StreetSq ftSoldClosed
Buffalo Creek Drive3 bd / 2 ba1,281$219K$171/sq ftJun 2026108 days
Buffalo Creek Drive3 bd / 2 ba1,236$195K$158/sq ftJan 2026116 days
Buffalo Creek Drive5 bd / 2 ba1,400$220K$157/sq ftAug 202587 days
Buffalo Creek Drive4 bd / 2 ba1,438$151K$105/sq ftJul 202514 days
Mckee Road4 bd / 2 ba1,663$245K$147/sq ftJul 202535 days

Show All Recent Sales

5 more sales, back to May 2024
StreetSq ftSoldClosed
Buffalo Creek Drive3 bd / 2 ba1,412$229K$162/sq ftOct 2024164 days
Buffalo Creek Drive3 bd / 2 ba1,104$225K$204/sq ftOct 202455 days
Mckee Road3 bd / 2 ba1,300$222K$171/sq ftOct 202496 days
Buffalo Creek Drive3 bd / 2 ba1,161$168K$145/sq ftJul 202434 days
Buffalo Creek Drive3 bd / 2 ba1,083$244K$225/sq ftMay 202471 days
Get Buffalo Creek Estates Value Updates by EmailNew sales and price changes near you, plus a free home value check. Unsubscribe any time.
Get Monthly Updates

Schools for Buffalo Creek Estates Homes

ElementaryMadison Cross Roads ElementarySchool guideMiddleSparkman MiddleSchool guideHighSparkman HighSchool guide

About These School Assignments

Per the listings; verify an address with Madison County Schools

Nearly every recent Buffalo Creek Estates listing shows the same assigned schools in Madison County Schools.

Assigned schools per the listings. Zone lines can change, so verify a specific address with Madison County Schools before you buy.

Around Buffalo Creek Estates

Map of Buffalo Creek Estates and Nearby Neighborhoods

The outline plus 1 nearby neighborhood with prices and homes for sale
Map: Buffalo Creek Estates and nearby Creeks Edge. Open the map search

Buffalo Creek Estates is in Toney, ZIP 35773. Use the map search to see every home listed under this name.

Neighborhood History

First platted 1988, about 119 lots

The first section of Buffalo Creek Estates was recorded with Madison County in 1988 and the most recent in 1996, 3 recorded plats in all, laying out about 119 lots on roughly 78 acres. Homes that have sold or listed recently were built from 1992 to 2000 and range from about 1,100 to 1,650 sq ft; 17 of the 17 with a recorded style were one-story. Lots run lots of about half an acre.

Compare Nearby Neighborhoods

Resale and new home sales in the last 12 months, nearest first. Tap a name to open its page.

NeighborhoodSalesMedianPer sq ft
Buffalo Creek Estatesthis page2$207K$164
Heritage Landing2$271K$162
Siddon AcresFirst platted 1964, 20 lots2$198K$165
Pine TreeFirst platted 1992, 40 lots2$224K$190
Graystone Estates9$489K$216

Compare More Nearby Neighborhoods

Wingate Subdivision and Edgewood Estates
NeighborhoodSalesMedianPer sq ft
Wingate Subdivision15$299K$156
Edgewood Estates3$300K$158

All sales, including new homes, so every row compares the same way. Neighborhoods with fewer than 2 sales are left out.

More nearby: Toney neighborhoods

Tools for This Neighborhood

Home Prices by School ZoneSee what each zone costsAsking vs. Selling PriceHow close sellers get to their first priceSell, Rent or Keep?Run the numbers on your homeHomes by FeatureSingle-story, workshops, storm shelters and more

Buffalo Creek Estates Questions

What do homes in Buffalo Creek Estates sell for?

As of November 1, 2026, 12 resale homes in Buffalo Creek Estates sold in the last 3 years at a median price of $223,500, or $166 per square foot. Most sales fall between about $151K and $245K depending on size.

How much is my Buffalo Creek Estates home worth?

Start with homes of a similar size: a typical 1,250 sq ft home here would fall around $200,000 to $255,000 based on recent resales. Updates, condition, lot and street can move a home outside that range, so for a real number request a free home value and we will compare your home with the closest sales.

How often do homes come up for sale in Buffalo Creek Estates?

Over the last 3 years, 12 resale homes sold here, about 4 a year out of roughly 119 lots, or about 1 home in 30 each year. That is about typical for the neighborhoods we track.

What schools are Buffalo Creek Estates homes assigned to?

Listings in Buffalo Creek Estates show Madison Cross Roads Elementary, Sparkman Middle and Sparkman High School in Madison County Schools. Zone lines can change, so verify a specific address with the district.

How old are the homes in Buffalo Creek Estates?

The first plat was recorded with Madison County in 1988 and the most recent in 1996. Homes that have sold or listed recently were built from 1992 to 2000.

Are most homes in Buffalo Creek Estates one story?

Yes. 17 of the 17 recent listings with a recorded style were one-story, typically about 1,250 sq ft.

Talk to a Local Agent About Buffalo Creek Estates

Buying, selling or just curious what your home would bring? We will give you a straight answer, with no pressure either way.

Call (256) 808-6861Schedule a Time to Talk

Source: ValleyMLS; deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Homes, townhomes and condos listed under the subdivision name Buffalo Creek Estates in ZIP 35773. Figures are medians as of November 1, 2026. Lot counts and plat years from Madison County subdivision plats. This is general market information, not an appraisal or a value opinion for any specific home.

Homes for sale in Buffalo Creek Estates

322 Buffalo Creek Drive, Toney
$246,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 21926822 MLS ⋅ 1,304 SqFt. ⋅ 35773 Zip Code ⋅ ACTIVE Status
Beautifully updated 3BR/2BA ranch in an established neighborhood. Spacious bedrooms with walk-in closets, granite countertops, tile backsplash, smooth ceilings, crown molding, updated lighting/ceiling fans, stainless appliances, LVP and carpet. Large utility/laundry room with pantry and updated hardware throughout. Cozy wood-burning fireplace with tile surround, hearth, and floating mantle. Covered front porch, large flat backyard with privacy fence, and concrete pad for outdoor use. Two-car garage; newer windows, HVAC, roof, and water heater. Convenient to major roadways, employment centers, shopping, and dining.

322 Buffalo Creek Drive, Toney
105 Indian Bluff Drive, Toney
$206,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 21932437 MLS ⋅ 1,240 SqFt. ⋅ 35773 Zip Code ⋅ ACTIVE Status
Charming 3 bedroom, 2 full bath ranch-style home situated on a large corner lot. The home features tile flooring in the kitchen and bathrooms, luxury vinyl plank flooring in the great room and dining area, and carpet in the bedrooms. Additional features include a spacious two-car garage and a chain-link fenced yard. Plenty of outdoor space for entertaining, pets, or enjoying the outdoors.

105 Indian Bluff Drive, Toney
1159 Toney School Road, Toney
$200,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 21925321 MLS ⋅ 1,105 SqFt. ⋅ 35773 Zip Code ⋅ ACTIVE Status
Fresh Paint!!! 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offers a spacious living room, functional galley kitchen with stainless steel appliances, generous bedrooms, and a practical floor plan ready for your personal touch. Enjoy a covered front porch, mature trees, and a fenced backyard. Conveniently located near shopping, dining, schools, and major roadways. Schedule your private showing today and imagine the possibilities!

1159 Toney School Road, Toney
338 Buffalo Creek Drive, Toney
$200,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 21923941 MLS ⋅ 1,176 SqFt. ⋅ 35773 Zip Code ⋅ ACTIVE Status
338 Buffalo Creek Dr is a 1-story Toney home. The kitchen features gray cabinetry, a tile backsplash, and appliances set over hardwood flooring with counter space for meal preparation. A vaulted main living area with hardwood floors connects to an adjoining dining space. Carpeted bedrooms with ceiling fans offer flexible use, served by full bathrooms that include a tub and vanity storage. A fully fenced backyard provides room for outdoor activity, and an attached two-car garage adds covered parking. Clean interior finishes complete this single-level residence throughout.

338 Buffalo Creek Drive, Toney
305 Buffalo Creek Drive, Toney
$199,999
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 21929059 MLS ⋅ 1,118 SqFt. ⋅ 35773 Zip Code ⋅ ACTIVE Status
Welcome to this beautifully renovated 3-bedroom, 2-bath home is move-in ready and situated in a serene, established community in Toney. Step inside to a fresh, updated interior featuring modern finishes throughout and a comfortable, functional layout. Outside, you'll find a nice, level lot with a spacious backyard offering plenty of room to relax, entertain, play, or enjoy the outdoors. The property also features an attached one-car garage and a large storage shed, providing plenty of additional storage space. With a fully renovated interior, great outdoor space, and a peaceful setting, this home is ready for its next owner.

305 Buffalo Creek Drive, Toney
Start Your Search

Listing data is derived in whole or in part from NALMLS and is for consumers' personal, non-commercial use only. All data should be independently verified..

This information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!