As of November 1, 2026, 2 homes are for sale in Mcculley Mill, asking $267,000 to $270,000 (median $268,500, about $98 per sq ft), and 1 more is under contract.
Over the last 3 years, 6 resale homes sold in Mcculley Mill, roughly one every six months.
J
F
M
A
M
J
J
A
S
O
N
D
When Mcculley Mill homes were listed over the last 3 years. Listings came in bunches; June was the busiest (2). The median home took 65 days from listing to closing in the last 3 years.
Waiting for the Right Home Here?Join the waiting list and we will email you the day a Mcculley Mill home hits the market. Free, and you can stop the emails any time.
For a typical 1,950 sq ft home here. Middle of the range: about $285,000. Based on 3 Mcculley Mill resales between 1,646 and 2,151 sq ft in the last 3 years.
Size-only estimate, not an appraisal. Kitchens, roofs, lots and streets can move a home above or below it. For your exact value, ask for a free, no-pressure walk-through.
What Homes Like Yours Sold For
Most sales: 1,600 to 1,999, median $248K
What resale homes in Mcculley Mill brought over the last 3 years, by size. Your home's row is a fair first look at its value. Most sales here were in the 1,600 to 1,999 group.
Home size
Sales
Median
Range
Under 1,600 sq ft
1
$223K
one sale$155 per sq ft
1,600 to 1,999
2
$248K
$247K to $249K$148 per sq ft
2,000 to 2,499
1
$250K
one sale$116 per sq ft
3,000 and up
2
$275K
$270K to $280K$76 per sq ft
How the Market Is Moving
65 days listing to closing, 97.0% of asking
These use the last 3 years because fewer than 3 homes resold here in the last 12 months.
65 daysmedian from listing to closing (2 of 6 closed within 60 days)
97.0%of the original asking price, median
3 of 6sellers lowered the price before selling
2listed now, with too few sales in the last year to measure supply
Homes for sale now ask about $98 per sq ft, below the $131 recent sales brought, partly because of the mix of homes on the market. Listings priced near recent sales have moved faster than the stretch-priced ones.
Recent Home Sales in Mcculley Mill
All 6 sales through the Valley MLS in the last 3 years. Street names only; days are from listing to closing.
Street
Sq ft
Sold
Closed
Tyler Mill Drive3 bd / 2 ba
1,435
$223K$155/sq ft
Apr 202555 days
Mill Valley Drive3 bd / 2.5 ba
2,151
$250K$116/sq ft
Jan 202563 days
Mill Valley Drive4 bd / 3.5 ba
3,580
$270K$75/sq ft
Sep 202485 days
Tyler Mill Drive4 bd / 3.5 ba
3,681
$280K$76/sq ft
Aug 2024349 days
Mill Valley Drive3 bd / 2 ba
1,646
$247K$150/sq ft
Jul 202428 days
Show All Recent Sales
1 more sale, back to June 2024
Street
Sq ft
Sold
Closed
Mill Valley Drive3 bd / 2 ba
1,716
$249K$145/sq ft
Jun 202467 days
Get Mcculley Mill Value Updates by EmailNew sales and price changes near you, plus a free home value check. Unsubscribe any time.
{"v":1,"mode":"place","title":"Map of Mcculley Mill and nearby neighborhoods","fallback":"wzmap-fallback","focus":"mcculley-mill","linkLabel":"View Neighborhood","searchPlaceholder":"Find a nearby neighborhood","asof":"November 1, 2026","metrics":[{"k":"med","label":"Price","title":"Median resale price","stops":[275000,300000,325000,400000],"colors":["#dbe7f3","#a9c6e4","#6f9fd0","#2E74B5","#1F3864"],"legend":["Under $275K","$275K to $300K","$300K to $325K","$325K to $400K","$400K and up"],"zeroLabel":"No recent resale"},{"k":"pps","label":"$/Sq Ft","title":"Median $ per sq ft","stops":[150,165,170],"colors":["#dbe7f3","#a9c6e4","#6f9fd0","#2E74B5"],"legend":["Under $150","$150 to $165","$165 to $170","$170 and up"],"zeroLabel":"No recent resale"},{"k":"act","label":"For Sale","title":"Homes for sale now","stops":[2,3],"colors":["#a9c6e4","#6f9fd0","#2E74B5"],"legend":["1","2","3 and up"],"zero":"#f3f5f8","zeroLabel":"None for sale","nodata":false},{"k":"y","label":"Era Built","title":"Typical year built","stops":[1960,1980,2000,2015],"colors":["#f6edcc","#e6cf7f","#C9A227","#8f7114","#4f3e07"],"legend":["Before 1960","1960 to 1979","1980 to 1999","2000 to 2014","2015 and newer"],"zeroLabel":"Unknown"}],"popup":[{"k":"med","label":"Median resale","fmt":"K"},{"k":"pps","label":"Per sq ft","fmt":"$"},{"k":"act","label":"For sale now"},{"k":"e","label":"Built"}],"f":[{"n":"Mcculley Mill","u":"mcculley-mill/","g":[["owgsEvleqO_BEcBs@iCmDa@wAFsBhAqBqAwEFuBpAsBjBm@xEHzHxBjAz@r@jB?|Lu@|F_@~@wAlAqBXqB_@"]],"c":[-86.8657,34.7787],"id":"mcculley-mill","med":249500,"pps":131,"act":2,"pen":1,"y":2010,"e":"2000s-2010s","w":36},{"n":"Craft Springs","u":"craft-springs/","g":[["gxhsEvofqOyBa@sCmB}AyCAyF~@qChCkCCiCb@_DxAeBlCs@jNp@fBbBv@tDPrNiAxGeAzAgBp@"]],"c":[-86.8705,34.7832],"act":1,"pen":4,"y":2025,"e":"2020s","tag":"New construction here"},{"n":"William R. Bailey Minor","u":"william-r-bailey-minor/","g":[["{pfsEnueqOe@bCiBvAgCP{B}@cAwBg@}G~@mDhDkAjDbAbAzB"]],"c":[-86.8689,34.7741],"act":0,"pen":1,"y":2025,"tag":"New construction here"},{"n":"Kingston Place","u":"kingston-place/","g":[["y{esEndgqOs@hB}AbA_Nd@gCsA{FeKQyAXoB~DyDeDoRlAiNn@mA|A_AtJ@fG`DdA|APpB}@jIm@rAwAbAp@dF@|FdCz@fAtBP`D"]],"c":[-86.8728,34.7719],"med":435000,"pps":181,"act":3,"y":2012,"e":"2000s-2020s"},{"n":"The Ridge","u":"the-ridge/","g":[["}iisEt`fqOmDk@eBaCDwE~AaClBg@zF?xHgB|Dd@hBzAb@nBSpBqE`EiHnB"]],"c":[-86.8698,34.7857],"med":265000,"pps":168,"act":0,"pen":1,"y":2014,"e":"2000s-2020s"},{"n":"Tremont","u":"tremont/","g":[["edfsE|jcqOe@dCwJdQmDx@cDoAu@gB@sBbD{L|CaIpCcA`Fn@|A|B"]],"c":[-86.8585,34.7728],"med":431000,"pps":170,"act":1,"y":2008,"e":"2000s-2010s","w":36},{"n":"Mcculley Manor","u":"mcculley-manor/","g":[["q{esEphdqOTtDyAbCcHdCqB?sAe@wCcDc@oBz@qMj@mB~C}A~C^pAtA"]],"c":[-86.8621,34.7711],"med":318000,"pps":168,"act":0,"y":2011,"e":"2000s-2010s","w":36},{"n":"Limestone Estates","u":"limestone-estates/","g":[["i}hsEnefqOcBfA_LlByD[qAsA]{AfAmKlAwAlBg@tBPzBxAfEwA|CX~AbBXfCg@jB"]],"c":[-86.8713,34.7867],"med":305000,"pps":150,"act":0,"y":1993,"e":"1980s-1990s","w":36},{"n":"Claymill Crossing","u":"claymill-crossing/","g":[["}ihsEfahqOaBdBiCZiKoA{AeAm@qAFaDpEsGzB{JjAsArAc@nB@fJbBxAjAf@tAKjC"]],"c":[-86.8794,34.783],"med":317000,"pps":150,"act":0,"y":1994,"e":"1990s","w":36},{"n":"Capstone","u":"capstone/","g":[["qefsEnigqOt@|BKpBaA~AeBr@mQ^}B}@gAwB@uBrAmF~AgAlE_ArHX"]],"c":[-86.8782,34.7728],"med":400000,"pps":181,"act":2,"y":1993,"e":"1980s-1990s"},{"n":"Walton Creek","u":"walton-creek/","g":[["gjisEpybqOoE_CgAeBWwLy@oF\\qB~@gAlHgB|Dj@lGbCbCfEZpFg@vCcApAzAxFM|AcA~AgBr@gGV{B}@"]],"c":[-86.8523,34.7863],"act":42,"pen":7,"tag":"New construction here"},{"n":"Jones Spring","u":"jones-spring/","g":[["_gjsEbsbqOgDWqBsCQkG|AiDV_DhAwAtAg@hELzBg@pBTnGxE~@fBg@rReCxB{Iv@cDiA"]],"c":[-86.8521,34.7905],"med":264500,"pps":160,"act":3,"y":2023,"e":"2020s","tag":"New construction here"},{"n":"Browns Crossing","u":"browns-crossing/","g":[["g~esEdciqOoGMeCgB{BzAgCNiBm@{@cAcDwGWoBnDeP|AmBdGu@`FTvHpE`BzGbB|AtE[tCjBb@dCWzBCtRyA`DqDr@qCiA"]],"c":[-86.8842,34.7706],"med":304500,"pps":165,"act":2,"pen":1,"y":2019,"e":"2010s-2020s"}],"base":"/athens/"}
Mcculley Mill is in Athens, ZIP 35613. Use the map search to see every home listed under this name.
Neighborhood History
Homes built 2008 to 2013
Homes that have sold or listed recently were built from 2008 to 2013 and range from about 1,450 to 3,700 sq ft; 5 of the 8 with a recorded style have two or more stories. That makes it mostly 2000s construction. Lots run a sixth to a fifth of an acre.
Compare Nearby Neighborhoods
These are sales in nearby neighborhoods, not in Mcculley Mill itself: resale and new home sales in the last 12 months, nearest first.
As of November 1, 2026, 6 resale homes in Mcculley Mill sold through the Valley MLS in the last 3 years at a median price of $249,500, or $131 per square foot. Most sales fall between about $223K and $280K depending on size.
How much is my Mcculley Mill home worth?
Start with homes of a similar size: a typical 1,950 sq ft home here would fall around $255,000 to $290,000 based on recent resales. Updates, condition, lot and street can move a home outside that range, so for a real number request a free home value and we will compare your home with the closest sales.
How fast do homes sell in Mcculley Mill?
The median home took 65 days from listing to closing in the last 3 years, and 2 of 6 closed within 60 days. Sellers got a median of 97.0% of their original asking price.
What schools are Mcculley Mill homes assigned to?
Listings in Mcculley Mill show Creekside Elementary, East Limestone Middle and East Limestone High School. A few listings near the edge show a different school. Zone lines can change, so verify a specific address with the school district.
How old are the homes in Mcculley Mill?
Homes that have sold or listed recently were built from 2008 to 2013.
Are homes in Mcculley Mill mostly two story?
Yes. 5 of the 8 recent listings with a recorded style have two or more stories, typically about 1,950 sq ft.
Talk to a Local Agent About Mcculley Mill
Buying, selling or just curious what your home would bring? We will give you a straight answer, with no pressure either way.
Source: Valley MLS listing data via Wyze Realty; deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Homes, townhomes and condos listed in Valley MLS under the subdivision name Mcculley Mill in ZIP 35613, sold or listed through Valley MLS. Figures are medians as of November 1, 2026; the numbers at the top may refresh when the page loads. This is general market information, not an appraisal or a value opinion for any specific home.
Listing data is derived in whole or in part from NALMLS and is for consumers' personal, non-commercial use only. All data should be independently verified..
This information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
