9 resales in 3 years; busiest months: December and October
Over the last 3 years, 9 resale homes sold in Buck Island, roughly one every four months.
J
F
M
A
M
J
J
A
S
O
N
D
When Buck Island homes were listed over the last 3 years. Listings were spread across 7 of the 12 months; December and October were the busiest (2 each). The median home took 183 days from listing to closing in the last 3 years.
Waiting for the Right Home Here?Join the waiting list and we will email you the day a Buck Island home hits the market. Free, and you can stop the emails any time.
For a typical 3,900 sq ft home here. Middle of the range: about $1,645,000. Based on 3 Buck Island resales between 3,921 and 4,386 sq ft in the last 3 years.
This is a size-based starting point, not an appraisal. Condition, updates, the lot and the street all move the number. A free walk-through with a local agent gives you the real figure.
What Homes Like Yours Sold For
Most sales: 4,000 and up, median $1.67M
Resale homes in Buck Island over the last 3 years, grouped by size. Find your home's size for the quickest honest starting point. Most sales here were in the 4,000 and up group.
Home size
Sales
Median
Range
Under 1,600 sq ft
1
$299K
one sale$239 per sq ft
1,600 to 1,999
1
$1.4M
one sale$729 per sq ft
3,000 to 3,999
3
$1.1M
$960K to $1.9M$309 per sq ft
4,000 and up
4
$1.67M
$1.25M to $2.45M$348 per sq ft
Price per Square Foot Over Time
$348 to $257: a clear drop from the peak
Each point is the median price per square foot of resales in the 12 months ending that month. It went from $348 in the year to November 2025 to $257 now: a clear drop from the peak.
Show the numbers
12 months to
Sales
Median price
Per sq ft
Nov 2025
4
$1,674,750
$348
Jan 2026
3
$1,499,500
$275
May 2026
3
$1,499,500
$275
Aug 2026
4
$1,374,750
$257
How the Market Is Moving
183 days listing to closing, 83.1% of asking, buyer-leaning market
These use the last 3 years because fewer than 3 homes resold here in the last 12 months.
183 daysmedian from listing to closing (3 of 9 closed within 60 days)
83.1%of the original asking price, median
5 of 9sellers lowered the price before selling
12.0 monthsof supply at the last year's pace, a buyer-leaning market
Homes for sale now ask about $1,199 per sq ft, well above the $309 recent sales brought, so expect some room to negotiate on the higher-priced listings. The typical seller here took about 17% less than the first asking price, so pricing right from day one matters.
Recent Home Sales in Buck Island
All 9 sales through the Valley MLS in the last 3 years. Street names only; days are from listing to closing.
Street
Sq ft
Sold
Closed
Pine Dale Drive2 bd / 1 ba
1,252
$299K$239/sq ft
Jul 2026125 days
Buck Island Drive6 bd / 5.25 ba
8,928
$1.25M$140/sq ft
Sep 2025248 days
Buck Island Drive5 bd / 4.25 ba
5,460
$1.5M$275/sq ft
Aug 2025392 days
Pine Dale Drive4 bd / 3.5 ba
4,070
$2.45M$602/sq ft
Aug 202554 days
Buck Island Drive6 bd / 3.5 ba
4,386
$1.85M$422/sq ft
Dec 202452 days
Show All Recent Sales
4 more sales, back to December 2023
Street
Sq ft
Sold
Closed
Buck Island Drive4 bd / 3.25 ba
3,103
$960K$309/sq ft
Oct 2024375 days
Buck Island Drive4 bd / 4.5 ba
3,921
$1.1M$281/sq ft
Jul 2024183 days
Buck Island Drive4 bd / 3 ba
3,021
$1.9M$629/sq ft
Dec 20230 days
Buck Island Drive1 bd / 1 ba
1,920
$1.4M$729/sq ft
Dec 2023408 days
Get Buck Island Value Updates by EmailNew sales and price changes near you, plus a free home value check. Unsubscribe any time.
{"v":1,"mode":"place","title":"Map of Buck Island and nearby neighborhoods","fallback":"wzmap-fallback","focus":"buck-island","linkLabel":"View Neighborhood","searchPlaceholder":"Find a nearby neighborhood","asof":"November 1, 2026","metrics":[{"k":"med","label":"Price","title":"Median resale price","stops":[250000,350000,450000,600000],"colors":["#dbe7f3","#a9c6e4","#6f9fd0","#2E74B5","#1F3864"],"legend":["Under $250K","$250K to $350K","$350K to $450K","$450K to $600K","$600K and up"],"zeroLabel":"No recent resale"},{"k":"pps","label":"$/Sq Ft","title":"Median $ per sq ft","stops":[225,250,270,290],"colors":["#dbe7f3","#a9c6e4","#6f9fd0","#2E74B5","#1F3864"],"legend":["Under $225","$225 to $250","$250 to $270","$270 to $290","$290 and up"],"zeroLabel":"No recent resale"},{"k":"act","label":"For Sale","title":"Homes for sale now","stops":[2,5],"colors":["#a9c6e4","#6f9fd0","#2E74B5"],"legend":["1","2 to 4","5 and up"],"zero":"#f3f5f8","zeroLabel":"None for sale","nodata":false},{"k":"y","label":"Era Built","title":"Typical year built","stops":[1960,1980,2000,2015],"colors":["#f6edcc","#e6cf7f","#C9A227","#8f7114","#4f3e07"],"legend":["Before 1960","1960 to 1979","1980 to 1999","2000 to 2014","2015 and newer"],"zeroLabel":"Unknown"}],"popup":[{"k":"med","label":"Median resale","fmt":"K"},{"k":"pps","label":"Per sq ft","fmt":"$"},{"k":"act","label":"For sale now"},{"k":"e","label":"Built"}],"f":[{"n":"Buck Island","u":"/guntersville/buck-island/","g":[["g_{pEptlmORrBgAlWk@tAiAz@yAX_BIqAm@{@kAkPsl@kp@{k@g@{@UyAL}An@oAjAw@bAS|AD~@Z|r@bf@hD|@z@h@v@nA"]],"c":[-86.2425,34.3944],"id":"buck-island","med":1400000,"pps":309,"act":1,"pen":1,"y":1987,"e":"1960s-2010s","w":36},{"n":"Gunters Landing","u":"/guntersville/gunters-landing/","g":[["g`|pElkomO_GrHcBx@wDQqBoCe@_F^sBdJwKpCsBdHqRLqHiZc^KsBj@iBvBqBlBm@tBJnAp@p^r\\hAnCMpBkDnMnErLL~AYzA}JzI"]],"c":[-86.2608,34.3909],"med":579500,"pps":203,"act":1,"y":2007,"e":"1990s-2000s","tag":"New construction here"},{"n":"The Grande At Gunters Landing","u":"/guntersville/the-grande-at-gunters-landing/","g":[["uq|pEtvlmOkKpMeC`@qC}@uAgC}@}Ef@yCiGyU^_DdB}ArBWxAV~NvJ`F~JNnB"]],"c":[-86.2492,34.3965],"med":550000,"pps":263,"act":7,"y":2024,"e":"2020s","w":36,"tag":"New construction here"}]}
Buck Island is in Guntersville, ZIP 35976. Use the map search to see every home listed under this name.
Neighborhood History
Homes built 1950 to 2022
Homes that have sold or listed recently were built from 1950 to 2022 and range from about 1,250 to 8,950 sq ft; 5 of the 8 with a recorded style have two or more stories. That makes it mostly 1980s and 1990s construction. Lots run lots of 1.6 acres to 3.6 acres.
Compare Nearby Neighborhoods
These are sales in nearby neighborhoods, not in Buck Island itself: resale and new home sales in the last 12 months, nearest first.
As of November 1, 2026, 9 resale homes in Buck Island sold through the Valley MLS in the last 3 years at a median price of $1,400,000, or $309 per square foot. Most sales fall between about $299K and $2.45M depending on size.
How much is my Buck Island home worth?
Start with homes of a similar size: a typical 3,900 sq ft home here would fall around $1,370,000 to $1,995,000 based on recent resales. Updates, condition, lot and street can move a home outside that range, so for a real number request a free home value and we will compare your home with the closest sales.
How fast do homes sell in Buck Island?
The median home took 183 days from listing to closing in the last 3 years, and 3 of 9 closed within 60 days. Sellers got a median of 83.1% of their original asking price.
What schools are Buck Island homes assigned to?
Listings in Buck Island show Dar Elementary, Dar Middle and Dar High School. Zone lines can change, so verify a specific address with the school district.
How old are the homes in Buck Island?
Homes that have sold or listed recently were built from 1950 to 2022.
Are homes in Buck Island mostly two story?
Yes. 5 of the 8 recent listings with a recorded style have two or more stories, typically about 3,900 sq ft.
Talk to a Local Agent About Buck Island
Buying, selling or just curious what your home would bring? We will give you a straight answer, with no pressure either way.
Source: Valley MLS listing data via Wyze Realty; deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Homes, townhomes and condos listed in Valley MLS under the subdivision name Buck Island in ZIP 35976, sold or listed through Valley MLS. Figures are medians as of November 1, 2026; the numbers at the top may refresh when the page loads. This is general market information, not an appraisal or a value opinion for any specific home.
Listing data is derived in whole or in part from NALMLS and is for consumers' personal, non-commercial use only. All data should be independently verified..
This information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
