Madison · ZIP 35758
Bartlett Mill Homes for Sale and Home Values
A compact neighborhood of about 19 lots, platted in 2020, with mostly two-story homes built around 2021, typically about 3,300 sq ft.
From Valley MLS data as of November 1, 2026. Compiled by George Lensch, Broker-Owner, Wyze Realty.
Bartlett Mill Homes for Sale
As of November 1, 2026, no Valley MLS home is listed for sale in Bartlett Mill. The most recent sale here closed in September 2026. Join the waiting list below and you will get an email the day the next one is listed.
Nothing is listed right now. When a home here goes on the market it will show in this spot.
See Every Home for Sale on the Map
Bartlett Mill Home Values
What's My Home Worth Here?
Enter your home's finished square footage for an instant range based on similar-size Bartlett Mill sales.
For another size, call (256) 808-6861 or request a free value.
$480,000 to $555,000
For a typical 3,300 sq ft home here. Middle of the range: about $510,000. Based on 4 Bartlett Mill resales between 3,229 and 3,596 sq ft in the last 12 months.
A rough range from size alone, not an appraisal. Updates, condition, lot and street can put a home outside it. Your exact value comes from a free, no-pressure walk-through with a local agent.
What Homes Like Yours Sold For
Median $549K
Resales in Bartlett Mill over the last 3 years, sorted into size groups, so you can compare like with like.
| Home size | Sales | Median | Range |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3,000 and up | 5 | $549K | $480K to $590K$163 per sq ft |
How the Market Is Moving
73 days listing to closing, 97.3% of asking, seller-leaning market
More than half of recent sellers cut the price before selling.
Recent Home Sales in Bartlett Mill
All 5 sales through the Valley MLS in the last 3 years. Street names only; days are from listing to closing.
| Street | Sq ft | Sold | Closed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pitalo Street5 bd / 3.5 ba | 3,300 | $480K$145/sq ft | Sep 2026155 days |
| Pitalo Street4 bd / 3.5 ba | 3,229 | $590K$183/sq ft | Aug 202641 days |
| Pitalo Street5 bd / 3.5 ba | 3,366 | $549K$163/sq ft | May 202644 days |
| Pitalo Street5 bd / 3.5 ba | 3,596 | $515K$143/sq ft | Dec 2025103 days |
| Pitalo Street4 bd / 3.5 ba | 3,229 | $590K$183/sq ft | Mar 202538 days |
Schools for Bartlett Mill Homes
About These School Assignments
Per the listings; verify an address with Madison City Schools
Most recent Bartlett Mill listings show these assigned schools; the outline crosses a zone line, so a few show another school (noted on the card).
Assigned schools per the listings. Zone lines can change, so verify a specific address with Madison City Schools before you buy.
Around Bartlett Mill
Map of Bartlett Mill and Nearby Neighborhoods
The outline plus 12 nearby neighborhoods with prices and homes for sale
Bartlett Mill is in Madison, ZIP 35758. Use the map search to see every home listed under this name.
Neighborhood History
First platted 2020, about 19 lots
Bartlett Mill was recorded with Madison County in 2020, laying out about 19 lots on roughly 4 acres. Homes that have sold or listed recently were built from 2021 to 2022 and range from about 3,250 to 3,600 sq ft; 5 of the 5 with a recorded style have two or more stories.
Compare Nearby Neighborhoods
Resale and new home sales in the last 12 months, nearest first. Tap a name to open its page.
| Neighborhood | Sales | Median | Per sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bartlett Millthis page | 4 | $532K | $154 |
| OakstoneFirst platted 2005, 151 lots | 12 | $470K | $168 |
| MillstoneFirst platted 2008, 211 lots | 9 | $605K | $170 |
| Willow CreekFirst platted 2016, 96 lots | 3 | $635K | $188 |
| FoxfieldFirst platted 2008, 148 lots | 2 | $876K | $203 |
Compare More Nearby Neighborhoods
Park Meadow and Bridgefield
| Neighborhood | Sales | Median | Per sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|
| Park MeadowFirst platted 1989, 301 lots | 12 | $338K | $171 |
| BridgefieldFirst platted 1994, 186 lots | 3 | $465K | $164 |
All sales, including new homes, so every row compares the same way. Neighborhoods with fewer than 2 sales are left out.
More nearby: Madison neighborhoods · ZIP 35758 market
Tools for This Neighborhood
Bartlett Mill Questions
What do homes in Bartlett Mill sell for?
As of November 1, 2026, 4 resale homes in Bartlett Mill sold through the Valley MLS in the last 12 months at a median price of $532,000, or $154 per square foot. Most sales fall between about $480K and $590K depending on size.
How much is my Bartlett Mill home worth?
Start with homes of a similar size: a typical 3,300 sq ft home here would fall around $480,000 to $555,000 based on recent resales. Updates, condition, lot and street can move a home outside that range, so for a real number request a free home value and we will compare your home with the closest sales.
Are any homes for sale in Bartlett Mill right now?
Not as of November 1, 2026. The last sale here closed in September 2026. Join the waiting list on this page and we will email you as soon as one is listed.
What schools are Bartlett Mill homes assigned to?
Listings in Bartlett Mill show Madison Elementary, Discovery Middle and Bob Jones High School in Madison City Schools. A few listings near the edge show a different school. Zone lines can change, so verify a specific address with the district.
How old are the homes in Bartlett Mill?
The first plat was recorded with Madison County in 2020. Homes that have sold or listed recently were built from 2021 to 2022.
Are homes in Bartlett Mill mostly two story?
Yes. 5 of the 5 recent listings with a recorded style have two or more stories, typically about 3,300 sq ft.
Talk to a Local Agent About Bartlett Mill
Thinking about a move in or out of Bartlett Mill? Ask us anything; you will get a plain answer and no sales pitch.
Source: Valley MLS listing data via Wyze Realty; deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Homes, townhomes and condos listed in Valley MLS under the subdivision name Bartlett Mill in ZIP 35758, sold or listed through Valley MLS. Figures are medians as of November 1, 2026; the numbers at the top may refresh when the page loads. Lot counts and plat years from Madison County subdivision plats. This is general market information, not an appraisal or a value opinion for any specific home.
No current listings, please check back later.