As of November 1, 2026, 7 homes are for sale in Magnolia Hill, asking $366,339 to $475,819 (median $438,369, about $166 per sq ft), and 2 more are under contract. All of the listings are new construction.
There have not been enough recent resales of similar homes in Magnolia Hill for an honest instant range. A local agent can compare your home with the closest sales here and nearby.
{"v":1,"mode":"place","title":"Map of Magnolia Hill and nearby neighborhoods","fallback":"wzmap-fallback","focus":"magnolia-hill","linkLabel":"View Neighborhood","searchPlaceholder":"Find a nearby neighborhood","asof":"November 1, 2026","metrics":[{"k":"med","label":"Price","title":"Median resale price","stops":[250000,350000,450000,600000],"colors":["#dbe7f3","#a9c6e4","#6f9fd0","#2E74B5","#1F3864"],"legend":["Under $250K","$250K to $350K","$350K to $450K","$450K to $600K","$600K and up"],"zeroLabel":"No recent resale"},{"k":"pps","label":"$/Sq Ft","title":"Median $ per sq ft","stops":[145,150,155,160],"colors":["#dbe7f3","#a9c6e4","#6f9fd0","#2E74B5","#1F3864"],"legend":["Under $145","$145 to $150","$150 to $155","$155 to $160","$160 and up"],"zeroLabel":"No recent resale"},{"k":"act","label":"For Sale","title":"Homes for sale now","stops":[2,3,6,9],"colors":["#dbe7f3","#a9c6e4","#6f9fd0","#2E74B5","#1F3864"],"legend":["1","2","3 to 5","6 to 8","9 and up"],"zero":"#f3f5f8","zeroLabel":"None for sale","nodata":false},{"k":"y","label":"Era Built","title":"Typical year built","stops":[1960,1980,2000,2015],"colors":["#f6edcc","#e6cf7f","#C9A227","#8f7114","#4f3e07"],"legend":["Before 1960","1960 to 1979","1980 to 1999","2000 to 2014","2015 and newer"],"zeroLabel":"Unknown"}],"popup":[{"k":"med","label":"Median resale","fmt":"K"},{"k":"pps","label":"Per sq ft","fmt":"$"},{"k":"act","label":"For sale now"},{"k":"e","label":"Built"}],"f":[{"n":"Magnolia Hill","u":"magnolia-hill/","g":[["osxsE`ezoOfFmDXo@BiDZaAYa@]XIzFwB~AQCFgSfYCuDbH{AjH}@xBuJdKkApBiJ@@_FxAFT[@yD"],["ivxsEjdzoOKQTwP`CGLjOqA`A"],["}vxsEbqyoOUfXOR_AAL}\\`G?GrBgCG"]],"c":[-86.6451,34.8631],"id":"magnolia-hill","act":7,"pen":2,"y":2025,"e":"platted 2025"},{"n":"Ivy Hills","u":"ivy-hills/","g":[["cvwsExi{oO`DE@|F]f@sCC"],["y|wsEl~{oOxDNX]I}HfDM^q@BmGvAG?zVwN?"],["oqxsExd{oOfc@NA~Aob@L}@i@"],["qpxsExi{oObXMCfE}XBm@e@"],["yvxsEzx{oO`@c@z\\?L|CKRs]B"],["wwwsEtv{oOm^GUX?`EqA@LuIl@mB~C{Ex@f@Mz@mB|BXt@b@w@zAp@~W?"],["ezxsEp~{oOzZCJxAq[B"]],"c":[-86.6542,34.8629],"med":314362,"pps":163,"act":11,"pen":2,"y":2022,"e":"2010s-2020s","tag":"New construction here"},{"n":"Garden At Ivy Hills","u":"garden-at-ivy-hills/","g":[["{gxsEbb|oOcD{@gLi@uAa@eBwC`@sDhByAtGwAdO@rCjAf@yBhB{AjCO|B~@`AzBh@pLs@vDs@jAsDfAuHHqCq@"]],"c":[-86.655,34.8634],"med":285000,"pps":144,"act":2,"y":2021,"e":"2020s","w":36,"tag":"New construction here"},{"n":"Gardens At Ivy Hills","u":"gardens-at-ivy-hills/","g":[["{swsEz_|oOcBxAcCViU{E_C_CAuDtAkBhBi@`QrAvE}FjBg@rBLvBfB\\|C"]],"c":[-86.6549,34.8631],"med":260000,"pps":151,"act":1,"y":2021,"w":36}],"base":"/toney/"}
Magnolia Hill is in Toney, ZIP 35773. Use the map search to see every home listed under this name.
Neighborhood History
First platted 2025, about 90 lots
Magnolia Hill was recorded with Madison County in 2025, laying out about 90 lots on roughly 56 acres.
Compare Nearby Neighborhoods
Resale and new home sales in the last 12 months, nearest first. Tap a name to open its page.
In the last 3 years, 10 new homes in Magnolia Hill closed through the Valley MLS at a median of $458,631. Resales here are still rare.
What schools are Magnolia Hill homes assigned to?
Listings in Magnolia Hill show Madison Cross Roads Elementary, Sparkman Middle and Sparkman High School in Madison County Schools. Zone lines can change, so verify a specific address with the district.
How old are the homes in Magnolia Hill?
The first plat was recorded with Madison County in 2025. New homes are still being built here.
Can I get a value for my Magnolia Hill home without an agent visit?
Yes. Request a free home value online and we will compare your home with the closest Valley MLS sales. A walk-through is only needed if you want an exact number.
Talk to a Local Agent About Magnolia Hill
Thinking about a move in or out of Magnolia Hill? Ask us anything; you will get a plain answer and no sales pitch.
Source: Valley MLS listing data via Wyze Realty; deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Homes, townhomes and condos listed in Valley MLS under the subdivision name Magnolia Hill in ZIP 35773, sold or listed through Valley MLS. Figures are medians as of November 1, 2026; the numbers at the top may refresh when the page loads. Lot counts and plat years from Madison County subdivision plats. This is general market information, not an appraisal or a value opinion for any specific home.
Listing data is derived in whole or in part from NALMLS and is for consumers' personal, non-commercial use only. All data should be independently verified..
This information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
